Problems with Spinal Breathing

Hello everyone, I’m having a few problems with spinal breathing. I find it very difficult to mentally transition from the endpoints – the perineum and the centre of the eyebrows – into the spine. I can’t seem to find a way to make these transitions feel natural and fluid.

No matter which shape I choose (e.g. ‘jumping’ from the endpoints to the spine, drawing a gentle arc from one point to another across the spine, etc.), it always feels somewhat stiff and not natural or effortless.

Is there a very straightforward and simple way of linking the end points to my breathing that still achieves the desired effect?

Just so you know: I tend to work more like a body scan rather than using visualisation. That suits me better.

Thank you all and best wishes,
Andy

2 Likes

Hi Andy,

Welcome to the forum!

It is very common to have a “clunky stage” when learning spinal breathing pranayama. It can even persist for some time if we tend to be over thinking the process. So the suggestion is to be easy with it. If you are ending inhalation at the brow and ending exhalation at the root, then the rest in-between will naturally take care of itself as the subtle neurobiology purifies and adapts, as it surely will.

A more detailed discussion from the forum AI is included below. Your spinal breathing practice will evolve, and all is good.

The guru is in you.

AYP Forum AI: In Advanced Yoga Practices (AYP), difficulty with endpoint transitions during Spinal Breathing Pranayama (SBP) is very common, especially in the beginning stages. The instruction is to handle these transitions smoothly and effortlessly without causing mental tension.

Here is how to resolve this difficulty:

1. Don’t Micro-Manage the Turn

The original instruction for SBP describes inhaling from the perineum up the spine to the center of the head, and then making a turn forward to the center of the eyebrows. However, you do not need to visualize or force a precise, sharp physical turn.

Treating the path as a direct, smooth line or gentle curve between the root and the brow is completely valid. The mental image is only meant to “prime the pump”—trying to force exact geometric turns creates unnecessary mind clutter and friction.

2. Focus on Landing at the Endpoints

The primary rule of SBP is simply to end up at the center of the eyebrows at the end of inhalation, and at the perineum at the end of exhalation:

  • At the top of the inhale: Allow your attention to arrive gently at the center of the eyebrows as your lungs fill.
  • At the bottom of the exhale: Allow your attention to rest at the perineum as your lungs empty.

How you get back and forth in between or how you turn around is far less important than touching both ends in every breathing cycle.

3. “Jump” the Attention if You Get Stuck

If you experience a delay, awkwardness, or “clunkiness” when transitioning from the endpoints back into the spine:

  • Skip over the stuck spot: Do not fight or analyze the obstruction at the endpoint.
  • Jump your attention directly to the opposite endpoint as the breath completes its cycle.

By “playing both ends through the middle,” you clear the central channel (sushumna) from both directions simultaneously. Over time, the transitions will clear up naturally without any effort.

4. Allow the Shift from Imagination to Feeling

It is completely normal for SBP to go through a “clunky stage” where the mental movements feel unnatural. As you maintain a daily routine, mental visualization naturally gives way to a tangible feeling of energy (ecstatic conductivity) moving along the spine. Once this energy flow awakens, the transitions will become fluid, automatic, and pleasurable without requiring deliberate visualization.

5. Keep the Breath Continuous and Unforced

Ensure your breath is slow, deep, and relaxed through the nose. Do not deliberately hold or suspend the breath at the endpoints unless it happens naturally on its own. Let the end of the inhalation smoothly turn into the beginning of the exhalation, and vice versa.


:sparkles:AI follow-up option: Would you like to explore how to add subtle sensory enhancements—such as tracing cool and warm currents—to help make the endpoint transitions feel more tangible?

3 Likes

Thank you so much for the detailed answer and all the tips. I’ll keep at it and trust that the “right” way will become clear to me.

Just so I understand: All of these examples in my pictures would be fine for getting started, and things will work out “right” on their own over time anyway.

I think for now, i would prefer the “red way”:

4 Likes

Hi Andy,

Yes, all of those options would be fine.

3 Likes

Hi:slight_smile:

I still have two questions, though. Focusing my attention on the spot between my eyebrows throughout the entire inhalation, then jump directly down and Focusing my attention on my perineum throughout the entire exhalation an so on —that’s not an option, is it? I “have to” travel the distance between the two points, right?

And if I “imagine” a straight line between the points, then the line would exit the body at one point… (see image). I know this is very theoretical, and I wouldn’t actually feel this exit, but would this option still be “correct” ?

Thank you all, and once again, thank you so much for your patience and your answers :slight_smile:

1 Like

Hi Andy,

Yes, it is fine to jump with your attention between the root chakra and ajna chakra. So, you would have your attention at ajna chakra for the whole of the inhalation and then have your attention at the root chakra for the whole of the exhalation.

And it is also fine to exit the body and come back in again if you are tracing a straight line between the ajna and the root. Spinal Breathing is not about the physical body.

The reason all of these options work is because of the way prana behaves in the subtle body. Prana flows towards the place where the attention is and will tend to flow along whichever energetic channel is the easiest for it to move along. So, if we inhale with our attention at the ajna chakra, prana will flow up the sushumna nadi towards that chakra. Then if we jump with our attention to the root as we exhale, prana will flow down from ajna chakra (where it was previously building-up), down the sushumna nadi to the root chakra. And so on as we continue to inhale and exhale. So, the practice will be purifying the sushumna nadi and activating the root and ajna chakra and all the chakras in between (2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th). And it does not make any difference if we used any of the coloured lines in the diagrams above, this same process would still happen.

At a certain stage we will begin to feel the prana flowing in the sushumna nadi and then we switch to tracing that channel with our attention, still going up on the inhalation and down on the exhalation. So, all these possible alternate routes are only relevant for beginners. They stop being relevant once prana is felt in the body.

There is more on this in Lesson addition 239.1 on the AYP Plus site:

This is from that Lesson addition:

We can awaken the spinal nerve just as easily by this method as by any other more complicated path for tracing the sushumna. Easier, as a matter of fact, because we will not be getting bogged down in excessive visualization (mind stuff). Like with deep meditation, we just easily favor the path between root and brow, whatever that means for us. It will not be exact. Like the mantra in deep meditation, it will change within our session, and over time. Over the long run of daily practice, the spinal nerve will expand from a small thread-like line to become a vast column of luminous ecstatic energy. Where is the spinal nerve in that? Still up and down the center, like the diagram shows. So the thing is not to micro-manage too much. Just favor the path and let it happen naturally. [Yogani]

3 Likes

Oh, that’s fantastic, Christi, thank you so much!

I think it’s easiest for me to start by keeping my focus firmly on the endpoints and jumping between them, rather than taking the path in between.

It’s really great to know that this works just as well :slight_smile:

So now I’ve got my practice together, and I’m going to practice with these two (DM and SBP) for a long time to come.

3 Likes

Welcome Andy. I have been practicing AYP thirteen years, and during the early years I too could not visualize without distraction, and the act of attention on top and bottom on the breath did the trick. Now tracing the spine is quite natural and is felt, and spinal breathing itself is less a structured, timed practice and more a gentle way to scan the body to effortlessly dissolve into DM. Your attention in all of yoga practices should be gentle in nature.

2 Likes

Thank you so much for your feedback :slight_smile:

I also think this simple version is a game-changer for me. I’ll be trying it out for the first time today, but I should be able to handle it really well.

It’s great how lively the community here is, and also how flexible the system is to meet individual needs.

I’m truly very grateful to have found AYP.

3 Likes

Hello everyone, I’m currently practising the technique of jumping back and forth between the two end points without consciously travelling the path in between.

Should I visualise something at the end points as well? A blue light (similar to the one with the channel) or just sense the spot?

Thanks and best regards, Andy

Hi Andy,

There is no need to visualise anything. You are just jumping with your attention between the two end points whilst inhaling and exhaling slowly and deeply. In time the middle will start to fill in automatically.

1 Like

Hi everyone, it’s me again :slight_smile:

Generally speaking, moving between the endpoints works quite well. I have no trouble at all locating the root chakra. With the Ajna chakra, however, it’s quite a bit trickier. The area is rather vague and I’m not quite sure where to focus my attention.

Would it make sense, before starting pranayama, to gently press the spot between my eyebrows with my finger so that I can feel it, and then let my attention rest there as I breathe in?

And during spinal breathing, my mind keeps wanting to switch things up (jumping straight to the next point, making a quick arc between the endpoints, moving along part of the spine and then jumping, etc.). Should I decide on one variation before the practice and stick to it for that session, or should I just let things happen as they come here too? Which, however, can be very distracting.

Thank you and best regards

1 Like

Hi Andy,

There is no harm in pressing the point between your eyebrows with your finger before starting Spinal Breathing Pranayama to get an idea of the end point. Just be sure not to keep pressing it during the practice.

And it also does not matter if your mind starts to fill-in the space between the end points during the practice. This is quite normal and is expected. Even if it is distracting for a while, that does not matter. Eventually you will be tracing the full sushumna nadi with your attention between the root and ajna chakras. But, you can allow that to happen in its own time. There is no rush.

3 Likes

Agree with Christi. “gently favoring” is a feature with AYP, so you need not focus too strongly on any of your practice. Just as you simply favor the mantra when you have left it, so too should you trace your spine, or hold a mudra, or spinal breathing. Over time as you practice your attention will have noticeable influence, and then you find the silence coming through.

2 Likes

Hi everyone,

Today, another variation came to me “quite naturally.” At the beginning of each inhalation and exhalation, I directed my attention to the respective endpoint. Then, more or less at the same time, I vaguely sensed the path through the spine. Is this also a valid approach? In other words, the more or less simultaneous “sensing” of the endpoint and the path along the spine?

And what also happened quite naturally was that my attention wandered just a short distance along the spine from one end point and then jumped back to the other end point. All in all, several different variations emerged on their own today.

It’s a strange situation. On the one hand, I can clearly feel something in my spine that draws my attention there. On the other hand, I notice how my body tenses up and gets slightly “cramped” when I try to “follow” the path from one point to another.

I think I should stick with jumping directly between the points for now to take some of the “pressure” off.

2 Likes

Hi Andy,

As long as you end up at the point between the eyebrows at the end of each inhalation and at the perineum at the end of each exhalation then it will be fine. What happens in between is not important. Your inner senses will begin to fill in the gap at some point, and when that happens, that is also fine.

No need to sweat the small stuff. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

Phew, in theory I understand all of this. In practice, though, I’m still pretty confused at times :smiley:

I have one more question about the eyes. I’ve noticed that my gaze sort of follows my attention—it moves up and down. Is that okay when I’m just starting out, or should I try to keep my eyes still?

Thanks, everyone :smile:

2 Likes

Hi Andy,

That’s fine when starting out. At some stage you may want to add shambhavi mudra to your Spinal Breathing practice and if you do, you will then be fixing your eyes in one place (upward toward the point between your eyebrows) even whilst your attention is moving between the ajna chakra and root chakra.

But, that is something for later on. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

Hello everyone,

I have also a question regarding SPB. I have tried many times and also change the duration like 5-10min to 2-3min. However I don’t feel anything when doing this breathing technique. Sometimes I feel that my energy is even more intense when doing SPB and I need to stop. Then I tried again when my energy has quiet down a little, but feel like SPB is not doing anything for me.

Is it normal that I don’t feel anything or any benefit at all, or is SPB just not the right breathing technique for me? Or am I doing it incorrectly?

Thx in advance

2 Likes

Hello cookie20

Usually one does the practices without expectations

Each sitting is different

So even when it seems you are not feeling anything, it does not mean that no progress is happening

Sometimes results are subtle and sometimes they are more obvious

Just keep the faith and keep practicing

2 Likes