Hi Qspadone,
I have been at this point. And this desire to recreate kick-started my interest in meditation. So, I don’t think that this initial obsession was a bad thing. It made me dive into meditation and yoga, and it made me practice regularly. It was this regular practice that not only slowly made the inner silence come forth more and more during meditation and also now gradually in daily life, but it is the very same practice that is now gradually unwinding my obsession with these experiences. I’m sure I’m still somewhat obsessed with them, but much less so than a year ago.
In summary, for me, an interest in meditation was kindled and a steady practice was fueled by a desire to recreate certain states, but then when this recreation gradually became a reality (for about a year, now most sessions of Deep Meditation and Samyama produce a thick lingering inner silence), the obsession with these states became less and less. And so I think striving for such a states can be a good thing, they can be valid bhakti for some time on the path. At least for me it was. Yogani’s advice
The suggestion is to let go of this obsession you have with creating experiences during meditation, or anytime.
would have been too much to ask from me. Letting go of the obsession right before and during my meditation sessions was crucial, yes, but if I had tried to quench this obsession also in daily life, there would have been no desire left to meditate at all. So following this advice back then might have been a dead end for me.
About the topic of looking around and trying out different practices. I have been very lucky with my sequence of “spiritual shopping” as it led me step by step into a stable practice I found with AYP.
If I had stuck to the first practice I encountered, Wim Hof breathing, it would have been a dead end for me, because the resultant state of Wim Hof breathing was not the bliss state I was looking for, albeit fascinating enough to open the world of pranayama and yoga in general for me. So, some “spiritual shopping” seems healthy until one finds what “works”. And what one considers “working” will gradually change as one’s desires change. It seems that AYP has the interesting quality of “working” for me even as my desires/obsessions gradually change. So I feel lucky that there was no urge to look elsewhere during nearly 3 years of practicing AYP.
So, my advice is to stick to whatever practice you feel “works” for you. But be patient with it, give it a few month or better a year before assessing and potentially switching again, and put on pause the striving to recreate states while sitting on the meditation cushion. If your striving to recreate a state of silence is there in your daily life and you suspect it to be the main reason why you currently want to do spiritual practices I wouldn’t try to quench it outside of practice.
My advice to treat a desire to recreate a certain state as a valid form of bhakti might not be a good one, so I would be curious to read Yogani’s thoughts on it.