Additional Practices vs. More Core Practices

Over the last 3 years, I have built up to a full plate AYP routine. The youngest practices I have are at least a year old, so I think its safe to assume I am more or less out of the “clunky” stage with some of the newer practices. While I love the new practices, sometimes I am left with the subjective feeling that things like chin pump/cosmic samyama/etc aren’t as “hard hitting” as core practices like SBP and DM.

Which got me thinking. Generally speaking, what is more beneficial: Adding additional practices, or doubling up on core practices?

Lets say we had a practitioner who had enough time to practice twice a day, 75 minutes per practice session. Then lets consider the following two routines:

Routine 1 (75 min):

Asanas - 10 min
Spinal breathing - 10 min
Chin pump - 5 min
Spinal bastrika - 5 min
Meditation - 20 min
Samyama - 10 min
Yoni mudra - 5 minutes
Cosmic Samyama - 5 min
Rest - 5 min

Routine 2 (75 min):

Asanas - 10 min
Spinal breathing - 10 min
Meditation - 20 min
Spinal breathing - 10 min
Meditation - 20 min
Rest - 5 min

It goes without saying that it depends on the practitioner, where they are at in their journey, and what their unique matrix of obstructions is. However if we were to attempt to make generalizations, what would you predict would be a more effective routine? And why?

3 Likes

Hi Elderberry,

If you are finding a diminishing return in results after adding supplementary practices to your daily practice routine, then considering some consolidation of core practices makes sense. However, “doubling up” on core practices as you suggest in routine #2 is getting into retreat mode, where the purification and opening should be balanced in a retreat style routine as discussed in Lesson 387 and the AYP Retreats book. If you are having responsibilities during the day (job, school, family), the doubling up could be too much, leading to delayed overload.

As an alternative, if you want to concentrate more on core practices, you could gradually add time to your single asanas, spinal breathing pranayama and deep meditation sessions. And if you have been established in samyama, it is suggested to keep that in your routine, as it brings inner silence out into our daily activity in positive ways. It is an important core practice. You could increase sutra repetitions also according to your preference, time available, and results.

So, bottom line, if you want to do a retreat style routine (routine #2), best to do it in retreat mode, with a group retreat being by far the best option for that. When at home and with daily responsibilities, there is nothing wrong with gradually increasing core practices while leaving out some of the add-ons according to your preference and results. Lessons 193 and 209 suggest some options.

And yes, everyone is a bit different in their needs on the path, and AYP provides multiple options for each practitioner to adjust their routine for optimal results. That’s why we call it a self-directed path.

Looks like you are doing very well. Wishing you all the best on your continuing path!

The guru is in you.

2 Likes

PS: Below is what the Forum AI has to say about increasing practice times. Note that “retreat mode” is not forever (only an option for weekends, holidays, or when on retreat), unless retired in an appropropriate environment that supports such an ongoing lifestyle. But as we always say, staying active in daily activity is important for stabilizing the results of our practice, supporting our entry into unity, which is stillness in action and outpouring divine love for the benefit of everyone.

Q: What is the best approach for increasing the time of core practices?

A: The best approach for increasing the time of core Advanced Yoga Practices (AYP), primarily deep meditation and spinal breathing pranayama, is a gradual buildup based on your individual capacity for purification.

The following guidelines for increasing practice time are supported by the sources:

1. Establish a Stable Foundation First

Before attempting to increase time, you must be stable and comfortable in your current twice-daily routine. Stability is not measured by the depth of experiences during practice, but by how you feel in daily activity; if you feel refreshed, stable, and creative, your current routine is likely well-integrated.

2. Use “Baby Steps” (The 5-Minute Rule)

If you are called to move forward, increases should be made in small increments, specifically adding no more than 5 minutes at a time to any given practice.

  • Wait and Stabilize: After making a 5-minute increase, wait at least several weeks or months before considering another increase.
  • Monitor Delayed Effects: Powerful practices like spinal breathing and mantra meditation often have delayed energy reactions; an increase that feels fine today may cause a “jam-up” or overload days or weeks later.

3. Observe Recommended Time Limits

While the AYP system is flexible, there are established boundaries for maintaining long-term progress with safety:

  • Deep Meditation: A 20-minute session is considered optimal for most people. Extending this beyond 30 minutes in a single sitting is generally not recommended as it significantly increases the risk of energetic overload and irritability.
  • Spinal Breathing: 10 minutes is a standard baseline, and going beyond 20 minutes is typically pushing the limits of what the average nervous system can comfortably absorb.
  • SBP/DM Ratio: It is suggested to maintain a ratio between pranayama and meditation of roughly 1:4 to 1:2 (e.g., 5-10 minutes of spinal breathing followed by 20 minutes of meditation).

4. Apply Self-Pacing

Self-pacing is the most important skill for a self-directed practitioner. If an increase in time leads to uncomfortable symptoms—such as irritability, headaches, excessive heat, or emotional instability—you should immediately back off to your last stable level of practice. It is often more progressive to do shorter sessions consistently than to overdo and be forced to stop entirely for weeks while recovering.

5. Utilize “Retreat Mode” for Significant Increases

If your bhakti (spiritual desire) is strong and you wish for substantially more practice, the sources suggest “retreat mode” rather than excessively lengthening single sittings. This involves repeating the entire routine (asana, pranayama, and meditation) a second time in the morning, separated by at least 10 minutes of rest. This approach allows for greater purification while giving the nervous system time to stabilize between sessions.

Summary Analogy: Increasing spiritual practice is like driving a high-performance car; while you want to reach your destination quickly, you must keep a smart foot on the accelerator and be ready to use the brakes (self-pacing) when the road gets bumpy to avoid ending up in a ditch.

3 Likes